Main Menu
Merritt Matheson Helping

Protecting What Makes Stuart, Stuart

Stuart's small-town character didn't happen by accident. It takes someone willing to say no - and to mean it.

Merritt has spent his time in public life doing exactly that. He's not anti-progress, but he believes new development should earn its place in Stuart - by meeting a high bar, paying its own way, and leaving the city better than it found it. That's a different standard than most commissioners apply, and Stuart residents have felt the difference.

During his time on the Commission, when he believed a project wasn't right for Stuart, he voted no. When he couldn't stop something outright, he fought to reduce its footprint, lower its height, cut its density, and extract every protection for residents and the environment that he could. Developers knew going in that Merritt's vote wasn't a given - and they came to the table differently because of it.

Here's the reality most people don't know: Florida law requires cities to approve developments that meet existing zoning rules. When a project checks every legal box, a no vote doesn't stop it - it just hands the developer grounds for a lawsuit the city will almost certainly lose, at taxpayer expense. Merritt understood that, so rather than casting symbolic no votes that cost taxpayers money and changed nothing, he focused his energy where it actually mattered: using every point of leverage to win real concessions, reduce real impacts, and make developers earn every inch.

Stuart is one of Florida's last authentic small towns. Merritt's record shows he intends to keep it that way.

Water Quality & The St. Lucie River

The St. Lucie River is in trouble - and the decisions made in the next few years will shape it for generations.

For decades, releases from Lake Okeechobee have fouled our waters, choked our coastline with algae, and hammered our fishing industry and local economy. Fixing this isn't just an environmental issue. It's an economic one, and a quality-of-life one.

During his time on the City Commission, Merritt was given a rare designation by his fellow commissioners: the official authority to represent Stuart directly in federal water negotiations. He used it. He spent four years working alongside Congressman Brian Mast's office, Friends of the Everglades and other stakeholders to shape how Lake Okeechobee is managed through the LOSOM (Lake Okeechobee System Operating Manual) process. Those efforts ultimately resulted in securing an agreement that prevents major discharges unless the lake reaches a critical threshold.

Now, a new round of negotiations begins in 2027 for LOSOM 2.0. The rules governing Lake Okeechobee will be rewritten again, this time factoring in new infrastructure that could change everything. The stakes could not be higher, and Stuart needs a commissioner at that table who already knows the players, understands the technical details, and has a track record of results. That's a big part of why Merritt is running.

Merritt Matheson Speech

Environmental Stewardship

Some candidates talk about the environment. Merritt has spent years in the rooms where the real decisions get made.

He co-founded the Martin County Forever Conservation Committee - the campaign that asked voters to invest in preserving our natural lands before they disappeared. Voters agreed: 64% approved a sales tax dedicated to conservation land purchases. So far, the county has acquired more than 3,000 acres, with more on the way.

Merritt currently serves as an appointed member on the Environmental Lands Acquisition and Management Oversight Committee (ELOC), which provides independent oversight on those land purchases.

He has also served for years as president of Indian River Keeper, dedicating himself to protecting and restoring the Indian River Lagoon, North America's most diverse estuary. As a governing board member of the Rivers Coalition, he continues that fight, working to stop harmful discharges from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie River and preserve the natural resources that define life on the Treasure Coast.

While serving as a city commissioner, he partnered with ORCA (the Ocean Research & Conservation Association) to improve Shepard Park - adding a natural shoreline buffer, a rain garden, and water quality testing in Fraser Creek, along with pervious parking surfaces that reduce runoff.

He also held the line against a proposed “lighthouse” tower feature on a north-of-bridge development that would have broken Stuart's four-story height limit and opened the door to future exceptions.

Good Government & Term Limits

During his first term, Merritt championed a charter amendment that permanently changed how Stuart government works - and he did it knowing the new rules would apply to him too.

In 2019, voters approved a charter amendment with 65% support. It did three things:

  • Extended commissioner terms from two years to four
  • Capped consecutive service at 12 years
  • Required any sitting commissioner who files to run for a different office to first resign their seat.

Merritt helped write the language, made the motion to put it to a vote, and pushed for its passage.

Good government also means respecting the process and outcomes you don't like. When a vote doesn't go your way, you work through legitimate channels - you don't break signed contracts or ignore state law. Merritt has watched the current Commission take a very different approach, one that has resulted in lawsuits, legal bills, and damage to city staff morale.

Merritt Matheson Group Picture

Community & Quality of Life

Beyond the big issues, Merritt spent four years focused on the details that make Stuart feel like home.

He championed the Creek District streetscape, including the mosaic sidewalk art installations that have become a defining feature of that neighborhood. He supported Shepherd Park improvements, including native landscaping, a rain garden, expanded parking, without sacrificing the park's character. He backed the marina north of the Roosevelt Bridge while blocking height-limit exceptions that would have undermined the city's development standards. He also pushed for a neighborhood compost bin program and the distinctive sailfish-shaped bike racks found throughout the city. These small touches reflect a community that cares about livability and identity.

Merritt believes Stuart is one of Florida's last authentic small towns. His record shows he means it.